Warning: Major spoilers for Lanterns Episodes 1–6.
HBO’s Lanterns may have already revealed the identity of its Manhunter, but there is a growing theory that the threat isn’t completely gone.
Zoe Macon was eventually exposed as the mysterious Manhunter hiding in Rushville, Nebraska. John Stewart confronted her during the devastating events of 2016, eventually killing her and removing her crystallized heart as proof that the threat had been eliminated.
But what if Zoe wasn’t the only Manhunter?
One character has quietly become increasingly interesting as the mystery has unfolded: Noah Macon.
Noah, the young grandson of Zoe Macon, has been present since the beginning of the series. At first, he appeared to be little more than a supporting character caught in the middle of the strange events surrounding his family.
However, after Episode 5, that interpretation has become much harder to maintain.
There are now several clues suggesting that Noah could be hiding a much bigger secret.
Zoe’s Final Words to Noah Are Extremely Suspicious
One of the biggest reasons behind the theory comes from Zoe herself.
Before the violent confrontation that ultimately led to her death, Zoe had a private conversation with Noah. Rather than simply saying goodbye, she told him not to forget everything she had taught him.
That line might not seem particularly important at first.
But after learning that Zoe was a Manhunter, it takes on an entirely different meaning.
What exactly had Zoe taught Noah?
Was she simply teaching him the lessons any grandmother would pass down to her grandson?
Or was she preparing him for something far more significant?
Lanterns hasn’t provided a definitive answer yet.
And that’s precisely why fans have started looking at Noah differently.
The theory that Zoe may have been preparing Noah to continue her work gained significant attention after Episode 5, with ComicBook.com specifically highlighting the possibility that Noah could be another Manhunter hiding within the Macon family.
Noah Was Already Connected to Zoe’s Secret
The biggest problem with Noah being completely ordinary is that he was unusually close to Zoe.
Zoe wasn’t simply a random member of the Macon family.
She was an ancient synthetic being who had apparently spent years living among humans while hiding her true identity.
And Noah was her grandson.
That means Noah was one of the people closest to the Manhunter during her time on Earth.
If Zoe really had another agenda, Noah could potentially have known more about it than anyone realized.
Even more interestingly, Zoe appeared particularly protective of him.
That could simply be explained by their family relationship.
But Lanterns has already demonstrated that appearances can be misleading.
The show spent much of its first half encouraging viewers to look at the Macon family and wonder which member was hiding something.
Zoe turned out to be the answer.
But perhaps she wasn’t the entire answer.
The “Miracle” Surrounding Noah Is Another Strange Piece of the Puzzle
Then there’s the mysterious story surrounding Noah’s birth.
The series establishes that Zoe previously helped Kerry Kane during a serious crisis, something Kerry describes in unusually significant terms.
That relationship becomes even more interesting when we remember what Zoe is capable of.
As a Manhunter, Zoe possesses technology far beyond anything available to ordinary humans.
Her abilities include advanced biological manipulation and regeneration, making the circumstances surrounding her connection to Kerry and Noah worth examining.
Could Zoe have done something extraordinary to help Kerry?
Could Noah’s existence somehow be connected to that technology?
Could he have been created, modified or otherwise altered by Zoe?
There is currently no confirmation that any of this happened.
But the show has deliberately left enough unanswered questions surrounding Noah’s origins to make the theory possible.
Noah Has the Perfect Cover
If Noah really were another Manhunter, he would have one enormous advantage over Zoe.
He was born into the community.
Zoe had to maintain a human identity.
Noah doesn’t have that problem.
He grew up in Rushville. He knows the people. He knows the town. He knows the Macon family.
And, most importantly, everyone already sees him as one of their own.
That makes Noah potentially the perfect character to hide a massive secret.
By 2026, ten years after the events surrounding Zoe’s death, Noah has grown into Rushville’s star quarterback. His transformation from the child John Stewart taught to throw a football into an all-state athlete is one of the show’s more subtle pieces of continuity.
ComicBook.com previously identified Noah as one of the possible Manhunter suspects, specifically noting that his seemingly ordinary position within Rushville could make the eventual reveal an enormous twist.
And now that the story has jumped forward to 2026, Noah is still there.
Ten Years Is a Long Time to Hide
The time jump might be the biggest thing working in Noah’s favor.
Lanterns has moved between 2016 and 2026, giving the story a decade of unexplored history.
We know what happened to Zoe.
We know what happened to Rushville.
But we don’t know everything Noah experienced during those ten years.
That creates an enormous opportunity for a hidden reveal.
If Noah is another Manhunter, he wouldn’t necessarily need to announce himself immediately after Zoe’s death.
He could simply continue living as Noah Macon.
Go to school. Play football. Make friends. Become part of the community. And wait.
A Manhunter capable of remaining undercover for years would be far more difficult to detect than one actively interfering with the investigation.
Hal Jordan’s Death Makes Noah Even More Interesting
Then there’s the 2026 mystery.
Hal Jordan is dead.
John Stewart has returned to Rushville and is trying to understand what happened to him. Episode 6 makes it clear that Hal’s death is now the central mystery driving the modern-day portion of the story.
That immediately raises another question:
Who killed Hal?
If Noah really is another Manhunter, he suddenly becomes a potentially important piece of that mystery.
He has a connection to Zoe. He has survived the destruction of the Macon family. He has remained in Rushville.
And unlike the other major Manhunter suspects, nobody appears to be watching him.
That does not mean Noah killed Hal. There is currently no confirmation of that.
But narratively, it would give the writers a very clean connection between the 2016 Manhunter story and the 2026 murder mystery.
What If Zoe Wasn’t the Manhunter’s End?
This is ultimately the most interesting possibility.
The reveal that Zoe was the Manhunter could have been the conclusion of the show’s first mystery.
But it doesn’t necessarily have to be the conclusion of the Manhunter storyline.
The comics have established that Manhunters are part of the larger mythology surrounding the Guardians of the Universe and the Green Lantern Corps.
So there is nothing inherently impossible about the show expanding the concept beyond Zoe.
In fact, doing so could explain why Lanterns introduced Noah so early.
A character who seemed relatively unimportant in the first few episodes could eventually turn out to have been one of the most important people in the entire story.
And that kind of twist would fit the show’s mystery-driven structure.
But There’s One Big Problem With the Theory
There is also a very good reason not to treat this theory as fact. The show has not confirmed that Noah is a Manhunter. Everything currently being discussed is circumstantial.
Zoe’s final words are suspicious. Noah’s relationship with her is unusual.
His origins raise questions.
He survived the events that killed several other members of his family.
And the ten-year time jump leaves plenty of room for something to have happened behind the scenes.
But none of those things proves that Noah is secretly a synthetic being. It is entirely possible that Noah is simply human and that the writers are using his connection to Zoe to explore the consequences of her actions.
There is also the possibility that the show is deliberately making Noah look suspicious because it knows viewers are looking for another twist.
For now, the evidence isn’t enough to call Noah the second Manhunter.
But if the show eventually pulls the trigger on that reveal, viewers may look back at Zoe’s final conversation with Noah and realize that Lanterns was warning us about him all along.
About the Author
