How “Braveheart” and “Outlaw King” Are Secretly Connected

Scotland’s rugged landscape, fierce warriors, and rich history have been the backdrop for countless tales of bravery and rebellion against tyranny. Two notable films that capture this spirit are “Braveheart” (1995) and “Outlaw King” (2018). Both movies delve into the lives of legendary Scottish leaders and their fight for freedom from English rule. While each stands on its own as a powerful portrayal of Scotland’s struggle, they are subtly interconnected in fascinating ways that reflect a broader narrative of resistance and legacy.

Understanding “Braveheart”

“Braveheart,” directed by and starring Mel Gibson, tells the dramatic story of William Wallace, a 13th-century Scottish warrior who led a rebellion against King Edward I of England. The film opens with Wallace’s peaceful life being shattered by English oppression, triggering his transformation into a relentless freedom fighter. It’s a tale of personal loss, revenge, and the larger-than-life quest for independence. The movie, with its stirring battles and iconic cry for freedom, has left an indelible mark on popular culture.

Enter “Outlaw King”

Fast forward to 2018, and Netflix released “Outlaw King,” directed by David Mackenzie, which shifts the spotlight to Robert the Bruce, another seminal figure in Scottish history. Set in the early 14th century, the film begins where “Braveheart” leaves off, depicting the aftermath of Wallace’s defeat and execution. Unlike Wallace’s straightforward, fiery rebellion, Robert the Bruce’s journey is more complicated, filled with political machinations, betrayals, and a war waged on multiple fronts. Chris Pine portrays Robert with a stoic determination, capturing the immense struggle to unite Scotland under his rule and continue Wallace’s fight.

How “Braveheart” and “Outlaw King” Connect

The most direct link between “Braveheart” and “Outlaw King” lies in their shared historical context. William Wallace and Robert the Bruce were contemporaries in Scotland’s prolonged fight against English domination. Wallace’s initial rebellion set the stage for Robert’s eventual ascension to the throne and his relentless efforts to secure Scotland’s independence.

In “Braveheart,” Robert the Bruce (played by Angus Macfadyen) is portrayed as a nobleman caught between his respect for Wallace and the political pressures of aligning with the English crown. This internal conflict is pivotal, as it underscores the burdens of leadership and the complexities of Scottish nobility’s divided loyalties.

“Outlaw King” essentially picks up Robert’s story, delving deep into his transformation from a cautious nobleman into a resolute king. The film portrays his unyielding resolve to take up Wallace’s mantle and continue the fight for Scottish sovereignty.

Both films explore themes of rebellion, sacrifice, and the undying quest for freedom. While “Braveheart” focuses on the initial spark of revolt and the inspirational fervour of Wallace’s leadership, “Outlaw King” addresses the enduring, often grueling nature of sustained resistance. It portrays the harsh realities of leadership and the toll it takes on Robert and his followers.

Robert the Bruce’s narrative in “Outlaw King” can be seen as a continuation and expansion of the struggle initiated by Wallace in “Braveheart”. This creates a broader, more comprehensive narrative of Scotland’s fight for independence, tying the two films together thematically.

Both films also share a common enemy: the English monarchy. In “Braveheart,” King Edward I (portrayed by Patrick McGoohan) is a ruthless, almost caricatured villain who embodies tyranny and oppression. His iron-fisted rule and merciless tactics set the tone for the conflict.

“Outlaw King” portrays Edward’s son, King Edward II (Billy Howle), who steps into his father’s shoes as Robert’s primary adversary. The portrayal of the English monarchy in both films continues the narrative of an oppressive regime that the Scottish heroes must overcome. The continuity of the antagonist, from father to son, underscores the persistent nature of the conflict and the intergenerational struggle for freedom.

Historical Accuracy and Creative License

It’s important to recognize that “Braveheart,” while emotionally resonant and cinematically celebrated, takes significant liberties with historical facts for dramatic effect. Characters, events, and timelines are often altered or exaggerated to heighten the narrative’s impact. For instance, the film depicts Wallace’s supposed relationship with Isabella of France, which is historically inaccurate, as she was a child during Wallace’s lifetime.

“Outlaw King,” on the other hand, strives for a greater degree of historical fidelity. It meticulously reconstructs the period’s settings, costumes, and events, even though some dramatization is inevitable in any historical film. The filmmakers have been praised for their attention to detail and their efforts to present a more realistic depiction of Robert the Bruce’s life and the complexities of his rebellion.

“Braveheart” has had a tremendous cultural impact since its release. It won multiple Academy Awards, including Best Picture and Best Director, and has become an enduring symbol of Scottish pride and resistance. Its stirring speeches, iconic scenes, and larger-than-life portrayal of William Wallace have cemented it as a classic in the genre of epic historical films.

“Outlaw King” continues this legacy, offering a more grounded, yet equally compelling narrative that appeals to modern audiences. Its release on Netflix allowed for global accessibility, reaching a wide audience and offering a nuanced portrayal of a pivotal figure in Scottish history. While it might not have the same immediate cultural impact as “Braveheart,” it enriches the historical narrative initiated by its predecessor.

While “Braveheart” and “Outlaw King” are distinct films, they are deeply connected through their portrayal of Scotland’s enduring struggle for independence. “Braveheart” introduces us to the fiery spirit of William Wallace, while “Outlaw King” delves into the relentless perseverance of Robert the Bruce. Together, they offer a powerful, interconnected narrative that celebrates the indomitable will of Scotland to remain free. For those intrigued by tales of heroism, sacrifice, and the quest for freedom, these films provide a compelling journey through one of history’s most inspiring chapters.